Politics

Supreme Court washes its hands off Ram temple donation theft: Prof. Hemantkumar Shah

Pro. Hemantkumar Shah Pro. Hemantkumar Shah | 28m ago · 2 min read
Supreme Court washes its hands off Ram temple donation theft: Prof. Hemantkumar Shah

Despite the involvement of millions of devotees, the Supreme Court has not handed over the case to the CBI.

The Ram Janmabhoomi temple in Ayodhya was not robbed once but 105 times. This was revealed in the investigation conducted by the SIT appointed by the Supreme Court. Nevertheless, the Supreme Court is not ready to take any action. Earlier this month, the Supreme Court delivered a very important verdict. This decision did not receive much attention as it was not covered by the mainstream media. The Supreme Court has disposed of various petitions seeking an independent investigation into the theft of donations at the new Ram temple built at Ram Janmabhoomi in Ayodhya.

The Yogi Adityanath government of Uttar Pradesh informed the Supreme Court that the police had filed an affidavit in this matter. Following this, the Supreme Court disposed of all these petitions! The court also told the petitioners that they could now assist the trial court in the investigation. The Supreme Court stated that this is not just a straightforward case between the accused and the government, but there is also a public interest involved, and therefore the court has allowed the petitioners to assist the trial court.

The court has also directed the trial court, i.e., the judicial magistrate, to take action in this matter according to the law. The court's stance is that if the accused are allowed to assist the court, then the petitioners should also be allowed to do so. The Solicitor General of India, Tushar Mehta, appeared as the lawyer for the Uttar Pradesh government. He informed the Supreme Court that the discrepancies occurred at the time of counting cash donations. Those involved in counting the money were the ones who took the funds.

A case was registered in June this year. The Supreme Court had previously constituted an SIT to independently investigate the entire matter. It had ordered that forensic auditors should also be included in this investigation. During this investigation, all CCTV footage, transaction ledgers, bank deposit records, and other materials were examined. The SIT stated in its investigation that the theft occurred 105 times during the counting of cash. A complaint was made in the court in Ayodhya last September.

The questions are:

(1) If public interest is involved in this matter, why is the Supreme Court not taking up the case itself?

(2) Will the judicial magistrate in Ayodhya under the Yogi government be able to conduct an independent investigation? If so, then people would not have to approach the Supreme Court.

(3) If the cash was stolen 105 times during counting, were the CCTV footages not reviewed daily? If not, then why not? If yes, then who reviewed them? Did the person who reviewed them inform their superiors or not? If they did inform, why was the theft not stopped and why was it allowed to continue for 105 times?

(4) This clearly implies that the theft of donations at the Ram temple was premeditated. The amount of stolen donations has been alleged to be up to ₹200 crore, but the SIT claims that only ₹2.70 crore was actually stolen. Regardless, theft is theft. The question is whether the thief will be punished or not?

The core issue is that the theft of donations is not an ordinary theft but a calculated conspiracy to steal the offerings made by people in faith towards Lord Shri Ram. Interestingly, despite the involvement of millions of devotees, the Supreme Court has not handed over this case to the CBI.

What will happen now? First the trial court, then the district court, then the high court, and finally the Supreme Court! Who knows what will happen by then? Only Lord Ram knows.

Pro. Hemantkumar Shah

Pro. Hemantkumar Shah

प्रो शाह जाने-माने अर्थशास्त्री हैं और गुजरात में लंबे समय तक अध्यापन के बाद लेखन और सामाजिक कार्यों में सक्रिय हैं।