Salman Khurshid defends India Summit, calls it not a secret meeting
A petition filed in the Supreme Court seeks to remove a video of Italian leader Giacomo Filibeck's speech and investigate the conference's permissions and foreign participation.
Amid political controversy surrounding the Bharat Summit held in Hyderabad, Congress leader and former External Affairs Minister Salman Khurshid stated that it was not a secret meeting. He mentioned that the event was conducted with government approvals and that the government itself issued visas to foreign delegates. In an interview with The Indian Express, he objected to linking the criticism of the government with anti-India sentiments. His statement came at a time when the issue regarding Italian leader Giacomo Filibeck's remarks at the summit has reached the Supreme Court.
The second edition of the Bharat Summit was held on November 13 and 14 in Hyderabad. According to the official program, sessions on topics such as international order, economic justice, and media freedom were held at the Hyderabad International Convention Centre. Information about the speakers and the program was available on a public website.
Before the summit, the Congress held a formal press conference on November 10. The published information from the party recorded the participation of Salman Khurshid, Gurdeep Singh Sappal, Telangana Congress President Mahesh Kumar Goud, and Minister D. Sridhar Babu. In the recent interview, Salman Khurshid described the summit's objective as enhancing dialogue with progressive political groups around the world. According to him, the Congress has been in opposition for a long time and wanted a platform to discuss foreign policy with its international counterparts. He also mentioned investment opportunities as part of the event.

He stated that the Congress party regularly engages in dialogue with socialist political parties from various countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom, and Australia. Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi also considers dialogue with foreign universities and leaders important, so that a better understanding can be built among those who share a similar perspective on the world. It is noteworthy that Hyderabad is the capital of Telangana, which is ruled by the Congress.
The most discussed part of the controversy is the speech by Giacomo Filibeck, Secretary-General of the Party of European Socialists. He repeated the Congress slogan ‘Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhod’ from the stage and spoke in support of Rahul Gandhi. The BJP has alleged that it is inappropriate to give a platform to any foreign political representative to intervene in India's domestic party politics in this manner. Salman Khurshid stated that no one can be instructed on what they can or cannot say. An individual has the right to express their views based on their understanding. He emphasized that protesting on international platforms is part of freedom of expression.
A delegation led by Telangana BJP President N. Ramchander Rao filed a complaint with the Foreign Regional Registration Office (FRRO) regarding this event. The complaint demanded an investigation and action against Giacomo Filibeck and the organizers. The BJP has alleged that anti-India comments were encouraged at the summit.
On the other hand, the Congress raised questions against the central government regarding the visas of the delegates attending the summit. Shashi Tharoor had claimed that out of 315 speakers who received approval from the Ministry of External Affairs, 115 were either denied entry or had their visas canceled. Norwegian journalist Hege Ling Swendson also mentioned that her travel was blocked and her visa was canceled at the last moment just before the trip.
Salman Khurshid stated that obtaining approval from the Ministry of External Affairs for speakers coming from abroad is a normal procedure. During the previous edition of the event, the government had stated that speakers from countries with which India does not have normal relations or where there is a state of war should not be invited. According to him, no such speaker was invited. He noted that despite some speakers' visas being canceled by the government, the event was successful. The spokesperson for the Ministry of External Affairs, Randhir Jaiswal, had stated regarding this controversy that visa-related decisions are a sovereign right of any country or government. The Congress was questioning the transparency of the reasons for the decisions, while the BJP was objecting to the political use of the event.
A petition filed in the Supreme Court seeks the removal of videos related to Giacomo Filibeck's speech and an investigation into the permissions for the summit and the participation of foreign delegates. According to reports, the court agreed to list it on November 20. The petition also includes a demand to preserve the videos and other electronic records. Salman Khurshid expressed hope that the court would rule in favor of the public and strengthen the fundamental values of democracy and transparency.
Salman Khurshid's statement has raised the central question of the debate. The question is what should be the acceptable limits of international political dialogue and how should dissent be evaluated? It is necessary to discuss public events, government approvals, and the content of speeches based on evidence. According to him, the Congress party will continue to hold the Bharat Summit in the coming years. The Supreme Court had on November 18 refused to issue immediate orders for the removal of videos related to Giacomo Filibeck's statements, and further hearings on the matter are scheduled for today, with a decision still awaited.
