Politics

Defending democracy and combating fascism is the need of the hour: Ram Puniyani

Ram Puniyani Ram Puniyani | 19 Nov, 2026 · 3 min read
Defending democracy and combating fascism is the need of the hour: Ram Puniyani

The BJP and its leaders have been loudly claiming that a large number of Bangladeshi infiltrators reside in India, but the facts do not support their claims.

Addressing the closing session of the India Summit 2026, Rahul Gandhi strongly criticized the large-scale removal of voters' names from electoral rolls and the collusion between politicians and big business houses. He stated that the rule of fascists began in India in 2014, and since then, democracy in India has been under threat. Currently, there is a nationwide movement against the SIR (Systematic Identification of Residents). Citizens have formed their groups and are continuously protesting against the SIR, as it has deprived millions of their right to vote.


According to the Electoral Democracy Index by the V-Dem Institute, India ranks 106th among 179 countries worldwide. India's score in this index is 0.38, the lowest since the Emergency imposed in 1975. The Institute states that India has become an elected dictatorship instead of a full democracy. The government has suppressed movements against the SIR and other issues very harshly. Those involved in these movements have been brutally beaten, despite the fact that they were completely non-violent. Our current rulers want to erase the names of their opponents from the electoral rolls so that, no matter how low their popularity may be, they continue to win elections.


PDFV-Dem_Institute_Democracy_Report_2026_lowres
/–100%
Loading document…


Earlier, the BJP attempted to strip people of their voting rights in Assam through the NRC (National Register of Citizens). However, contrary to their claims, among the 20 lakh people in Assam who did not have the necessary documents to prove their citizenship, 12 lakh were Hindus. The BJP and its governments and leaders have been loudly claiming that a large number of Bangladeshi infiltrators reside in India. However, the facts do not align with their claims. The ruling party in India has already infiltrated the judiciary. It has a deep influence over the judiciary and has turned many autonomous institutions into its puppets, trying in every way to eliminate the democratic rights of the people. In such a situation, it does not seem wrong for Rahul to call them fascists.


The founders of the RSS were those sections of society who were against the pro-democracy movements that began during British rule. They were feudal lords, landlords, and priests who wanted to maintain the values of hierarchy from the feudal era. These people not only stayed away from the anti-British struggle but also opposed social-democratic reform movements. They did not want workers to have the right to form unions, nor did they want Dalits and women to gain education. The Indian National Congress played a significant role in guiding the national movement, fighting a long battle to make the country independent and democratic.

On one side, the Muslim League and on the other, the RSS-Hindu Mahasabha were demanding separate nations in the name of their respective religions. Later, the RSS opposed the Indian Constitution and our tricolor flag, justified the values of Manusmriti, and opposed the values of freedom, equality, and brotherhood enshrined in the Indian Constitution.

They were enamored with fascism and openly praised the values and methods of fascism. Dr. B.S. Munje of the Hindu Mahasabha was significantly influenced by Mussolini. After returning from the Round Table Conference held in London, he stopped in Italy to meet Mussolini. He was also quite impressed by Balilla, one of the most important components of the Italian fascist regime. In her book ‘Shadow of Swastika’, Marzia Casaroli provides a detailed account of this meeting. The book is subtitled “The Interconnections of Indian Extremist Nationalism, Italian Fascism, and Nazism.”



Similarly, the second Sarsanghchalak of the RSS, M.S. Golwalkar, praised Nazi Germany in his book “We or Our Nationhood Defined.” He writes, “...to maintain the purity of its nation and culture, Germany shocked the world by freeing the country from Jews. This is the highest expression of national pride. Germany also showed that races and cultures with fundamental differences can never unite. This is a lesson for us in Hindustan that we can learn and benefit from (We or Our Nationhood Defined).”

Golwalkar established the two fundamental principles of Hindu nationalist politics that form the basis of today’s BJP politics. First, he labeled Muslims, Christians, and communists as internal enemies of the country, and second, he glorified the caste and gender hierarchies enshrined in Manusmriti.


In the 2014 general elections, Narendra Modi was the prime ministerial candidate. A large number of foreign companies and agencies were used to enhance his image. Even before becoming Prime Minister, an aura was created around him. Sociologist Ashis Nandy conducted an interview with Narendra Modi, after which Nandy concluded that he is a pure fascist. He did not use the term fascist as an insult but as a diagnosis of a disease. Nandy writes, “About a decade ago, when Narendra Modi was nothing, just a small RSS propagandist wanting to gain a position in the BJP, I had the fortune of interviewing him. After the interview, I had no doubt that he is a pure, clinical fascist. I do not use the term ‘fascist’ as a slur. For me, it is a disease that includes not only the ideology and personality traits of the individual but also who or what their source of inspiration is.”


Fascist governments promote the corporate sector. Almost all corporate houses in India are having good days, and it seems like one has hit the jackpot. Policies are being formulated in such a way that vast wealth continues to flow into the coffers of large companies. No one cares about what will happen to the common man. The fascism in India is slightly different from that in Germany. While in Germany, race was used as a weapon to spread hatred, in India, religious identity is being used for this purpose. Issues like the Ram Mandir, sacred cows, love jihad, etc., have played a significant role in strengthening Hindu nationalism.

It is interesting that after the 2002 riots, a German delegation that visited Gujarat felt as if they were in Germany decades ago. In Gujarat, school textbooks glorify Hitler. Mahatma Gandhi described the RSS as “a communal organization with a fascist mindset.”

PDFpyarelal ji
/–100%
Loading document…


Today, as we stand against the SIR, we must understand that the BJP government is not an ordinary government. It has used every possible means to come to power and now wants to remain in power indefinitely. This is despite the fact that a large number of people have turned against it due to its anti-people policies. The SIR poses the greatest threat to Indian democracy as it is depriving a large number of people of their voting rights, who might vote against the BJP. The government has already taken control of the entire system by appointing its people in important institutions and departments.

The values of the Constitution and the freedom movement are now in serious danger. But we must not lose hope. We must have faith that our efforts will restore democratic principles.

(Translation from English by Amrish Hardeniya. The author used to teach at IIT Mumbai and is the president of the Center for Study of Society and Secularism)

Ram Puniyani

Ram Puniyani

इतिहासकार राम पुनियानी आईआईटी मुंबई में पढ़ाते थे और वर्तमान में सेंटर फॉर स्टडी ऑफ सोसाइटी एंड सेकुलरिज्म के अध्यक्ष हैं।