Jairam Ramesh calls 2027 census a joke, questions religion and caste listing
Congress leaders Kharge and Rahul Gandhi have previously raised objections to this in a letter to PM Modi.
Congress party's General Secretary Jairam Ramesh has raised serious questions about the method of recording religion and caste in the online form for the 2027 census, stating that the census portal displayed 287 options under the 'other' category for the religion question, which have until now been officially considered sects and part of the six major religions of India. However, these options were later removed. Jairam Ramesh said that the 2027 census is becoming a joke in many ways, and if not corrected in the coming days, it could have serious consequences.
Under this form, people were given the option to fill in their and their family's information online in the second phase of the census. Recently, this facility was launched for the states of Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Goa, and Uttarakhand, where elections are also to be held. In this form, the question regarding religion included options for Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Buddhist, and Jain, along with 'other', and upon selecting 'other', names such as ISKCON, Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, Sanatan, Shri Ram, Shri Krishna, Valmiki, Bishnoi, Sarna, Shia, Sunni, Methodist, and Pentecostal appeared, which have until now been considered sects.

The presence of names of religious institutions, faith traditions, and sects within different religions in the same list has created confusion about how these responses will be recorded in the final figures, as Shia and Sunni are branches of Islam, while Methodist and Pentecostal are branches of Christianity. Even after this list was removed, the option for 'other' remained, under which people can write their religion themselves.
A government official informed the national newspaper 'The Hindu' that these names were prepared for the assistance of enumerators and aimed to reduce spelling errors. The question arises as to how these suggestions appeared as a complete list on the open portal for the general public. An official from the Census Commissioner’s office stated that the facility to write the name of one's faith under 'other' is still available as before.
Jairam Ramesh, referring to the list of religions, said that where predetermined options are needed, they have not been provided. He also cited examples of other castes besides Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. An open column has been kept in the form for these castes, where people can write the name of their caste themselves. The government has argued that apart from the lists of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, there is no single common list of all castes in the country available so far.
Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge and Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi had previously raised objections to Prime Minister Narendra Modi in a letter. They stated that the name of the same caste can vary in different regions, and its spelling can also change, and an individual might write the name of their sub-caste instead of the main caste. If there is no clear method for counting such responses together, individuals from the same community could be recorded under different names. Both leaders had demanded predetermined options and a fresh consultation on the questions posed, citing the caste surveys of Bihar and Telangana as examples.
According to the Ministry of Home Affairs, people in the designated areas of a total of four states can fill in online information until November 30, and this form contains a total of 40 questions related to the family and its members. Upon submission, a identification number will be provided, which must be given to the enumerator visiting the house. For families that do not fill out the online form, enumerators will record their information at home. The population count will take place door-to-door from December 1 to January 4. After that, from January 5 to 9, there will be a phase to include those who were missed.
Currently, the list of 287 options for the religion question has been removed. Available reports do not clarify how the responses recorded during the display of the list will be counted in the final figures. The controversy regarding caste also revolves around how responses recorded under different names, spellings, and sub-castes will be grouped together. What people fill in the online form and how those responses are used to prepare the final figures has brought Jairam Ramesh's objections to the center of debate. Questions are continuously being raised about the method and purpose of the census being conducted by the government, and it remains to be seen how the government will utilize this information for public welfare once the process is completed.
