Rahul Gandhi and Nirmala Sitharaman engage in war of words

Rahul Gandhi's statement comes amid the controversy surrounding N. Chandrasekaran's reappointment as Tata Sons chairman.

The Tata Group, considered one of the largest and most trusted industrial families in the country, is currently in the news due to internal strife. The dispute is not just about who will lead Tata Sons, but also whether the company should be listed on the stock market. However, this internal industry dispute is now taking on a political dimension. Yesterday, in the Lok Sabha, Congress MP and Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi alleged that the Tata Group is being “criminally destroyed.” Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman retaliated to his statement, accusing him of linking business matters to politics.

Rahul Gandhi's Allegation and Nirmala Sitharaman's Response

Advertisementहिंसा अहिंसा और भगत सिंह

हिंसा अहिंसा और भगत सिंह

अशोक कुमार पाण्डेय की नयी किताब

अमेज़न से खरीदें→

Rahul Gandhi wrote on X on Wednesday morning, “Tata is being criminally destroyed and no business leader has the courage to say a word. How long will you remain silent? Until they take you over too?”

About six hours later, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman responded to Rahul Gandhi's allegations. She stated that it is not right to label business and legal matters as criminal without solid grounds. She also accused Rahul of repeatedly targeting the achievements of Indian industries and businessmen.

However, the matter did not stop there. In the evening, Rahul Gandhi responded to the finance minister on X, raising another question. He asked why a meeting took place on October 7 last year at Amit Shah's residence with Noel Tata, Chairman of Tata Trusts, N. Chandrasekaran, Chairman of Tata Sons, and other trustees. Rahul questioned what business or legal matter warranted the presence of these individuals at the Home Minister's house?

The details of what was discussed in this meeting have not been made public.

What is the Truth Behind the Meeting Claims?

According to a report by India Today dated October 8, 2025, Noel Tata met with Amit Shah and Nirmala Sitharaman in New Delhi. The report cited PTI, stating that Chandrasekaran was also present. Along with Noel Tata, TVS Motor Company's Chairman Emeritus Venu Srinivasan and senior lawyer Darius Khambata were also included. The meeting took place at Home Minister Amit Shah's residence, but the official agenda has not been disclosed.

A report by CNBC-TV18 claimed, citing sources, that the central government is monitoring the growing tensions within Tata Trusts. The report alleged that four trustees—Darius Khambata, Jahangir H.C. Jahangir, Pramit Jhaveri, and Mehli Mistry—were attempting to undermine Noel Tata's leadership. However, these allegations have not been independently verified.

Amid all this, the question arises as to what the real reason for the dispute is.

What is the Dispute?

To understand the dispute, it is essential to comprehend the relationship between Tata Trusts and Tata Sons. According to a report by MINT, Tata Trusts is led by Noel Tata. It is a group of 14 charitable trusts that engage in social and public welfare work. Seven of these trusts hold shares in Tata Sons.

The Sir Dorabji Tata Trust holds 27.98 percent and the Sir Ratan Tata Trust holds 23.56 percent of Tata Sons. Combined with the stakes of five smaller trusts, these philanthropic institutions hold a total of 65.9% of the company's shares. The Shapoorji Pallonji family holds an 18.38% stake. Nine companies of the Tata Group hold 12.86 percent, and the remaining 2.87% shares are held by seven individuals.

Tata Sons is the principal holding company of the group. It comprises 26 companies listed on the stock market. By the end of March 2026, the total market value of these companies was approximately $277 billion. Therefore, any decision regarding the control and future of Tata Sons is crucial for the entire group.

Questions on Chandrasekaran's Reappointment

N. Chandrasekaran is the Chairman of Tata Sons. His current term is set to end in February 2027. On August 12, he stated that he would not wish to continue in this position. He cited Noel Tata's opposition, which he claimed had been ongoing since the beginning of the year.

However, on September 17, the board of Tata Sons decided to reappoint him as chairman for a third five-year term. At the board's request, Chandrasekaran also agreed to this. However, Noel Tata and Tata Trusts objected to this decision. Tata Trusts questioned the legality of the appointment process, raising concerns about whether the company's rules were properly followed in making the decision. Following this, Noel Tata wrote five letters to the board, questioning the decision-making process and alleging that a complete record of the discussions held in the meeting was not maintained.

Conflict Over Stock Market Listing

The second major issue in this dispute is the listing of Tata Sons on the stock market. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) classified Tata Sons as a large non-banking financial company in September 2022 and directed it to be listed on the stock market by September 2025. After repaying a loan of approximately ₹22,000 crore, Tata Sons sought to cancel its registration as a core investment company in March 2024 to avoid listing. However, the RBI rejected this request on September 12 and instructed compliance with the regulations.

Tata Trusts is also not in favor of the company being listed on the stock market. Consequently, the differences regarding the company's future among the trusts, the board, and the regulatory body have intensified.